Why You Do
Stupid Sh*t
7
Why You Do Stupid Sh*t

Chapter 7

Capture

Before examining the specific domains where real sabotage operates, there is a mechanism worth naming, because it operates in every one of them and it operates in your life right now.

Capture is what happens when the approval-seeking programming locks onto a person, institution, or narrative and begins organizing behavior around maintaining that approval. Family capture. Workplace capture. Ideological capture. The captured person is not weak or stupid. They are running programming that evolved for exactly this purpose, because in the Paleolithic environment, the approval of the group was not a social comfort. It was a survival requirement.

The capturing power of one's current cultural group — the coalitional psychology operating in your present-day political, professional, and social identity — is the hardest form of capture to see, because it is the water you are currently swimming in. Dietrich Bonhoeffer, writing from a Nazi prison in 1943, observed that stupidity is more dangerous than wickedness, because the wicked man can be reasoned with, while the person fully captured by the group's narrative cannot be. He was not describing intellectual incapacity. He was describing what happens when ordinary people of normal intelligence surrender their judgment to the group and defend its narrative with a ferocity that makes reasoning with them impossible. He watched this happen to intelligent people in real time. Intelligence does not protect against capture. It makes people better at defending the positions the programming has already determined, not better at questioning them. This is not a phenomenon confined to 1940s Germany. It is the programming running right now, in everyone reading this sentence, and including me.

There is a particular form of delusion that success produces, and it is worth naming because it runs exactly counter to what most people assume. The assumption is that people who rise to positions of power and influence must see things more clearly — that their success reflects superior judgment. The framework predicts the opposite. The higher you climb within any institutional structure, the more your identity, income, and social position depend on the approval of that structure. The programming's investment in maintaining your position increases with every promotion. The cost of seeing the system clearly — of recognizing the L.I.E. operating in your own institution — becomes enormous, because clear sight threatens everything the programming has built. This is why the blue-collar worker so often sees what the executive cannot. The regular person has less invested in the delusion. They can afford to call it what it is. The executive, whose entire life has been organized around success within the system, often cannot afford to see the system at all. This is not a claim just about other people. Those of us who have built careers, reputations, or identities inside institutional structures are the most captured and the most confident in our clarity.

This goes deeper than incentives. There is strong evidence that human intelligence evolved primarily for social purposes — tracking alliances, managing reputations, navigating status hierarchies, reading who is up and who is down. If that is what intelligence actually is, then what we call "the smartest person in the room" is often the person whose programming is most finely tuned to the social system, which means most dependent on it, not most independent of it. The person we admire for their intelligence is frequently the person most thoroughly captured by the very structure they are navigating so skillfully. Intelligence in service of capture produces more sophisticated justification, not more honest perception. The most successful people in any institutional hierarchy are often the most captured — and the most confident in their clarity, which is the capture operating at its most complete.

Share this chapter

Get the Book + Audiobook Bundle

Available at selfsabotage.com

Order Now